Financial Planning11 min read

What Is an In-Kind Transfer? When It's Tax-Free and When It Isn't

Selling a $100,000 position to move it can cost $9,000 in federal tax. Moving the shares in kind triggers none. Here's how in-kind transfers work, and when you owe tax even though nothing was sold.


Say you own $100,000 of an index fund in a taxable brokerage account. You paid $40,000 for it years ago, and you want it at a different firm.

You can sell, move the cash, and buy the fund again. That realizes a $60,000 gain. At a 15% federal rate, which is the most that most people pay on long-term gains, that's $9,000 before any state tax.

Or you can ask for an in-kind transfer. The shares themselves move, nothing is sold, and the federal tax bill is zero.

It isn't always tax-free, though. On an RMD form or a Roth conversion screen, moving shares without selling them is fully taxable.

What Is an In-Kind Transfer?

An in-kind transfer moves an investment as it is, share for share, from one account to another, instead of selling first and moving dollars.

What decides the tax is where the shares land. If they stay with the same owner in the same kind of account, nothing is owed. If they leave the pre-tax retirement system for a taxable account or a Roth, their value that day is generally income, sale or no sale (employer stock is a partial exception, covered below). If they go to a different owner, gift or inheritance rules apply.

SituationTaxable?Who starts itWhat can go wrong
Taxable account to another firmNoYou, at the new firmHoldings the new firm can't take may be sold
IRA to the same type of IRA elsewhereNoYou, usually at the new firmA check made out to you starts a 60-day clock
Pre-tax 401(k) to a traditional IRA, direct rolloverNoYou, through the plan20% is withheld if the plan pays you instead
Employer stock from a 401(k) to a taxable accountPartly now, the rest when soldYou, through the planRolling the stock into an IRA gives up the tax break
RMD taken in sharesYes, on that day's valueYou, at the IRA custodianThe price drops and the RMD comes up short
Roth conversion in sharesYes, on that day's valueYou, at the IRA custodianIt can't be undone
Gift of shares to a personNo income taxThe giverShares given at a loss lose the loss
Gift of shares to a charityNo, and it may be deductibleThe giverShares held a year or less deduct at cost only
Inherited accountThe move itself, noThe beneficiaryA check to a non-spouse IRA heir is a distribution

Is It Better to Transfer In Kind or Sell and Rebuy?

Back to the $100,000 position with the $40,000 cost. This illustration assumes a 15% federal rate (higher earners can owe more), no state tax, and 6% annual growth for ten years. None of those are predictions.

Sell, move cash, rebuyTransfer in kind
Tax paid now$9,000$0
Invested at the new firm$91,000$100,000
Value after 10 years$162,967$179,085
Tax if sold then (15% of the gain)$10,795$20,863
Left after tax$152,172$158,222

The transfer doesn't erase the gain. Your $40,000 cost comes along, and the tax comes due whenever you sell. What you get is ten more years of growth on the $9,000, worth about $6,050 here. If the shares eventually go to a charity or to your heirs, the gain may never be taxed at all.

If you wanted out of that fund anyway, selling first isn't a mistake. And for a position worth less than you paid, selling can be the better move. It books a loss you can use, as long as you don't buy the same fund back within 30 days before or after, which would make it a wash sale.

Moving a Brokerage Account to Another Firm

Most firm-to-firm moves run through the Automated Customer Account Transfer Service, or ACATS, and you start at the new firm, which requests the account from the old one. FINRA's transfer rule gives the old firm one business day to validate the request and three more to complete it, which comes to about a week in practice. Transfers outside ACATS, such as some from banks and insurers, can run longer, and the SEC says it isn't uncommon for them to take up to 30 days. Some holdings may not transfer, such as funds sold only by your old firm and fractional shares, and any that get sold in a taxable account are taxed like any other sale; how to fire your financial advisor covers those and the other steps of leaving an advisor.

Does Cost Basis Transfer With the Shares?

For most holdings, yes. When a covered security changes firms, the old firm has to send the new one a transfer statement within 15 days of settlement showing each lot's adjusted basis and original purchase date, so a lot you've held more than a year should still show as long-term. Covered generally means stock bought after 2010 and mutual fund shares bought after 2011.

Older lots fall outside those rules, and their basis may arrive blank. Download the cost basis detail from the old firm before you start.

Moving an IRA or 401(k): Direct Transfer or 60-Day Rollover?

Inside a retirement account, gains aren't taxed until money is distributed, so selling before a move costs nothing in tax. What matters is how the account travels.

A direct transfer, which the IRS calls a trustee-to-trustee transfer, goes from one IRA custodian straight to another. It isn't a rollover and isn't taxed because nothing is paid to you. Shares can move in kind this way, though IRAs may take longer than a regular brokerage account.

In a 60-day rollover, the money or shares are paid to you and you redeposit them. There's less room for error. Miss the 60 days and it's generally a taxable distribution, with a possible 10% additional tax if you're under 59½. You get one IRA-to-IRA rollover in any 12-month period, a limit that doesn't apply to direct transfers. A workplace plan withholds a mandatory 20% from a payout made to you, and you make up the difference from other money. If an IRA paid you shares, you have to redeposit those same shares, not cash from selling them.

For a 401(k), ask the plan for a direct rollover to an IRA of the same type, pre-tax money to a traditional IRA. Check first if you left that employer in or after the year you turned 55 and you're under 59½: withdrawals from the plan can avoid the 10% additional tax, and that exception doesn't apply to IRAs.

The employer stock exception. Company stock in a 401(k) is the main case where taking shares out of the retirement system in kind can be the better tax move. It requires a lump-sum distribution, meaning your entire balance in all of that employer's plans of the same kind, paid within one tax year after an event such as leaving the employer or reaching 59½, with the employer shares going to a taxable account. You pay ordinary income tax on what the plan paid for the shares. The growth above that, called net unrealized appreciation, isn't taxed until you sell, and then as long-term capital gain.

On shares worth $200,000 that the plan bought for $50,000, to pick round numbers, that's $50,000 of ordinary income now and $150,000 of long-term gain whenever you sell. Growth after that day follows the normal holding-period rules. If you're under 59½, the 10% early distribution tax can apply to the $50,000 unless an exception fits.

Roll those shares into an IRA and the option is gone, because what comes out of a traditional IRA is ordinary income. Get this reviewed before you sign rollover paperwork.

Is an In-Kind Transfer Taxable? RMDs and Roth Conversions

Required minimum distributions. Once you reach age 73, you have to take money out of traditional IRAs each year. It doesn't have to be cash: you can move shares to a taxable account instead. Their value that day is ordinary income and becomes your new cost basis, and the holding period starts over. You stay invested, but the tax is the same as if you'd sold inside the IRA and withdrawn cash.

If the price drops mid-transfer, you can come up short, and a shortfall may face a 25% excise tax, or 10% if corrected within two years. And with no cash coming out, there's nothing to withhold tax from, so plan to pay it another way.

Roth conversions. Two of the three ways to convert are direct transfers, and the holdings can move in kind instead of being sold. As with an RMD, that keeps you invested and saves no tax: the converted value is income for the year. A conversion made after 2017 can't be reversed, and at RMD age the RMD has to come out first. Our post on Roth conversions covers what drives the amount and when it's worth getting help.

Giving Shares to Family or Charity

To a person. A gift doesn't ordinarily affect your own income tax. The recipient generally takes over your basis, and under IRS holding period rules your purchase date as well. Give an adult child shares you bought at $10 that are now worth $100, and they owe tax on $90 a share if they sell at that price. The gain is taxed at their rate, which can be 0% at lower incomes, unless the kiddie tax applies.

A gift above the annual exclusion, $19,000 per person for 2026, means filing a gift tax return. The excess counts against a lifetime exclusion of $15 million for 2026, so most people never owe gift tax.

Don't do this with shares that are down. When the value at the time of the gift is below your cost, the recipient's basis for figuring a loss is that lower value, so the loss disappears. Sell those yourself, take the loss, and give cash.

To a charity. For shares held more than a year, you can generally deduct the full market value if you itemize, up to 30% of your AGI in a year, with no gain to report. Shares held a year or less are generally deductible only up to what you paid. Starting in 2026, itemizers can deduct only the charitable gifts above 0.5% of AGI.

Inherited Accounts

Custodians will generally retitle inherited taxable shares into an account in your name without selling them. The basis generally resets to the value on the date of death, and any gain when you sell is treated as long-term however briefly you've held the shares.

An inherited IRA is stricter. If the owner wasn't your spouse, you can't roll it over. The only way to move it is a trustee-to-trustee transfer into an inherited IRA titled in the deceased owner's name for your benefit, and a check made out to you is a distribution. Spouses have more choices. See what to do with an inheritance for the rest.

Checking the Transfer and Getting Help

Whichever transfer you're doing, check share counts when it settles, then check basis lot by lot two to three weeks later, since the old firm has 15 days after settlement to send it.

None of the paperwork needs a professional. A brokerage or IRA transfer is one form at the receiving firm, and an in-kind RMD or Roth conversion is a request to your custodian. The harder calls are the ones you can't reverse: the employer stock election, the size of a Roth conversion, what to do with a large embedded gain. A CPA can run those numbers. So can an advice-only planner, who will give you specific recommendations and leave the forms and trades to you, in your own accounts. Based on data from 97 advice-only planners on the Advice-Only Network (March 2026), hourly work runs a median of $300 per hour.

Ready to find an advice-only financial advisor?

Every advisor in our network charges transparent fees with zero product sales or AUM charges.

Browse Advisors