How Advice-Only Advisors Give Investment Advice (You Place the Trades)
How advice-only advisors give investment advice: a written allocation, a specific fund for each account, and an order of trades you place yourself, sometimes with the planner watching on a screen share. A full walk-through, and who it doesn't suit.
Here's the kind of line an advice-only planner puts in an investment plan without ever logging in to the client's accounts: "Rollover IRA: use the $100,000 in cash to buy VXUS."
In the example this post walks through, a couple gets a line like that for each kind of account they own. Following all of them moves $400,000, and the couple enters every order themselves. The planner is paid a flat fee that was agreed before any of it started. (The couple is an illustration with invented numbers, not a real client.)
That's how advice-only advisors give investment advice, and it surprises people who assume a planner who doesn't manage money can only speak in generalities. The recommendations are as specific as the ones a portfolio manager would act on. What changes is who places the trades, where the accounts sit, and how the planner gets paid.
This post covers those mechanics. The definition is in what advice-only planning is.
Do Advice-Only Advisors Give Investment Advice? What Arrives in Writing
They do, and it comes as a document. A thorough investment section answers five questions:
- What's the target? A percentage for stocks and for bonds across the whole household, usually with a split between US and international stocks.
- Which fund goes in each account? By name and ticker, chosen from what that account offers. In a 401(k), that usually means the plan's own fund list.
- Why that account? This is asset location. Vanguard's first rule is to put taxable bonds in tax-advantaged accounts, and it estimates that good placement can add up to 0.3% a year in after-tax returns for certain investors, a benefit it calls modest next to the allocation decision.
- When do I rebalance? A date to check and a trigger for acting. Vanguard's guidance is that an annual rebalance is optimal for many investors.
- What do I do first? An order of trades: what to sell, what to buy, and what to leave alone.
Cody Garrett, a CFP® professional, described his own advice-only practice in a 2021 article on Kitces.com, including screen-share calls where he taught clients to check cost basis, open and transfer accounts, and reallocate their investments. As he put it in a reply to a reader, "I help clients select the specific securities, but they implement the trades."
One Engagement, From First Meeting to Trades Placed
The tickers below show how detailed a plan gets. They aren't a recommendation for you.
A couple, both 48, has $600,000 in five accounts. (Their emergency savings sit at a bank, outside these figures.)
| Account | Balance | Invested in |
|---|---|---|
| 401(k) at a current employer | $280,000 | S&P 500 index fund |
| Rollover IRA | $100,000 | Cash |
| Roth IRAs (one each) | $70,000 | Six individual stocks and a sector fund |
| Joint brokerage | $150,000 | $100,000 in an S&P 500 index fund bought years ago for $60,000, plus $50,000 cash |
The first meeting is about them: what the money is for, when they'll need it, and what they did the last time markets fell. Then they send statements for every account and the fund list from the 401(k). Here's what else to bring.
When the planner adds it up, the household is 75% in US stocks and 25% in cash. There are no bonds and nothing outside the US, and the rollover IRA has never been invested.
At the second meeting the planner recommends 70% stocks and 30% bonds, explains the reasoning, and hands over an order of trades:
- 401(k): exchange $180,000 from the S&P 500 index fund into the plan's bond index fund.
- Rollover IRA: use the $100,000 in cash to buy VXUS, a total international stock ETF.
- Roth IRAs: sell everything in each account, then buy VTI, a total US stock market ETF, with the proceeds.
- Joint brokerage: use the $50,000 in cash to buy VXUS. Don't sell the S&P 500 fund.
The result is $270,000 in US stocks (45%), $150,000 in international stocks (25%), and $180,000 in bonds (30%).
All the bonds sit in the 401(k). That's asset location at work, and it's why no single account looks balanced on its own.
The S&P 500 fund in the joint account stays put, because selling it to buy something slightly broader would realize a $40,000 gain. The IRS says the rate on long-term gains is no higher than 15% for most people, and at that rate the swap would cost $6,000 in federal tax, before any state tax. Every sale in the plan happens inside a retirement account instead, where selling has no tax impact.
The rebalancing rule fits in one sentence. Each January, add up all five accounts, and if stocks are above 75% or below 65% of the total, move money between the two 401(k) funds until they're back at 70%. The plan also covers new 401(k) contributions, because the election for future paychecks is often a separate setting from an exchange of the existing balance.
Do You Have to Place Your Own Trades? How a Screen Share Works
Yes, though not necessarily alone. In this example the couple books a third call, logs in to their own accounts, shares their screen, and works down the four lines while the planner watches. Along the way the planner explains what's on the screen, such as why cash from a sale can show as unsettled until the next business day.
Share your screen and keep your password to yourself. SEC staff have said an adviser who holds a client's ID and password has custody if that access would let it withdraw money or move it out of the client's name, and an advice-only planner has no need for that.
What Happens After the Trades
That depends on what you paid for. With a one-time plan, the engagement ends. The SEC's view is that an adviser hired for a one-time plan and a one-time fee is unlikely to have a duty to monitor your investments afterward unless the two of you agreed otherwise. The January check is yours.
A monthly ongoing arrangement usually means scheduled check-ins and someone to ask between them, though what's included varies by planner. The planner can prompt the yearly rebalance and revisit the allocation after a job change or an inheritance. You still place the trades.
Based on data from 97 advice-only planners on the Advice-Only Network (March 2026), the median one-time comprehensive plan costs $3,000, the median hourly rate is $300 per hour, and the median monthly ongoing fee is $250 per month.
For scale, an SEC investor bulletin describes asset-based fees as annual rates such as 0.25%, 1%, or 2% of the assets being managed. At 1% of the $320,000 outside the 401(k), this couple would pay $3,200 a year, or $6,000 if the firm also managed or billed on the 401(k). That fee buys a firm that places the trades in the accounts it manages and keeps watching them. Whether that's worth it comes down to how much of this work you want to keep.
Is an Advice-Only Planner Still a Fiduciary If They Never Touch Your Accounts?
Yes. The duty comes from giving advice for pay, and it doesn't depend on holding or trading your money.
A person who's paid to advise others about securities is an investment adviser, and advisers generally must register with the SEC or with a state. Neither of the two powers people associate with advisors is required for that:
- Discretion is the authority to make trades in your account without your sign-off on each one.
- Custody, under the SEC's custody rule, is holding your funds or securities, or having the authority to obtain possession of them. Authority to deduct a fee from your account counts.
An advice-only planner, as the Advice-Only Network uses the term, has neither. They can't trade your account or take money from it, and you pay their invoice yourself.
The SEC's 2019 interpretation says the fiduciary duty applies to the entire adviser-client relationship, covers state-registered advisers as well as SEC-registered ones, and reaches services ranging from a single financial plan for a one-time fee to ongoing portfolio management. Separately, a planner who holds the CFP® certification is bound by the certification's Standards of Conduct to act as a fiduciary whenever they give a client financial advice.
To check, search the firm and the planner by name at adviserinfo.sec.gov. The firm's Form ADV brochure has to describe its services, the amount of client assets it manages, and whether it bills you or deducts fees from your accounts. A firm that's advice-only across the board should show no assets under management and fees that are billed, not deducted.
Advice-Only vs. Robo-Advisor vs. Asset Manager
| Question | Advice-only planner | Robo-advisor | Asset manager with discretion |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who chooses the investments? | The planner recommends, you decide | Software, from an online questionnaire | The advisor, who tells you afterward |
| Who places trades and rebalances? | You | The platform | The advisor |
| How is it paid? | Flat fee, hourly, or monthly ongoing | Usually a percentage of assets, sometimes a subscription | Usually a percentage of assets |
A robo's or an asset manager's fee generally comes on top of the funds' own expenses, so the cheapest way to own index funds is still to hold them yourself. Some people combine models, hiring an advice-only planner for the plan and a robo for the trading.
What You Take On, and Who This Doesn't Suit
When you hold the accounts, these jobs are yours:
Execution. You enter the orders. A wrong ticker or the wrong account is your mistake to catch, which is the reason to do the first round with the planner watching.
Staying put. Nobody stands between you and the sell button in a bad month. Morningstar estimates that the average dollar in US funds earned 8.7% a year over the decade ending in 2025, while the funds themselves returned 9.9%, and it traces the gap to the timing and size of investors' purchases and sales. That covers all fund investors, advised or not, so it isn't a verdict on any one model.
Knowing when to come back. A new job, an inheritance, or a retirement date five years off can make the plan stale, and after a one-time plan nobody is watching for that but you.
If you know you won't log in every January, or entering a $180,000 order would rattle you even with help, a manager's fee pays for something you'd value. Couples should also plan for the one who does the investing dying first. Having both of you on the screen share helps.
Some people don't need to hire anyone. If you have one or two retirement accounts and decades to go, a single target-date index fund sets the allocation and rebalances for you, and the only cost is the fund's expenses. The same Morningstar study found that investors in allocation funds like these kept more of their funds' returns than investors in nearly every other kind of fund.
If you're interviewing advice-only planners, ask each one whether they'll stay on a screen share while you place the trades, and what it costs to come back with a question in six months. Then ask to see a sample investment section. It should have a target, a fund for each account, and an order of trades.
Ready to find an advice-only financial advisor?
Every advisor in our network charges transparent fees with zero product sales or AUM charges.
Browse Advisors