Retiring Before 65? One Extra Dollar of Income Can Cost You Thousands in Health Insurance
The 400% subsidy cliff is back for marketplace health insurance. For a 60-year-old couple, crossing it by a dollar can mean losing a tax credit worth about $27,000 a year. Here's where the line sits for your household, what counts toward it, and how to stay on the right side.
Picture two 60-year-olds who have both stopped working and are buying their own health insurance for 2027. If their income for the year comes to $86,560, they get a premium tax credit of roughly $27,000. If it comes to $86,561, they get nothing.
Nothing phases out between those two numbers. Here's the arithmetic, using national averages, so treat it as an illustration and not a quote. KFF puts the average 2027 benchmark silver premium at $703 a month for a 40-year-old. Under the federal default age curve, a 60-year-old is charged about 2.1 times what a 40-year-old is, which works out to about $1,493 a month each, or about $35,800 a year for the couple. A household under the income limit is expected to pay at most 10.22% of its income toward that plan in 2027, about $8,800 here. The tax credit covers the other $27,000.
Go one dollar over the limit and the couple owes the full $35,800. Your own premium depends on your county, your ages, and the plan you pick, but the shape of the problem is the same everywhere.
How the Cliff Came Back
The Affordable Care Act has always limited premium tax credits to households with income between 100% and 400% of the federal poverty level. For tax years 2021 through 2025, Congress suspended the upper limit. People above 400% still got help, and their cost for a benchmark plan was capped at 8.5% of income.
That expired at the end of 2025. The House passed a bill to extend it in January 2026, and the Senate put it on its calendar in February and has not voted on it. As of this writing, the old rule is the law for 2027 coverage.
Premiums have made the drop steeper. KFF reports that benchmark premiums rose 26% from 2025 to 2026 and another 13% for 2027. People under the line are mostly shielded from those increases, because the credit grows with the premium. People over it absorb every dollar.
Two caveats. Congress could still act, so check the current status before you make an irreversible move based on this. And a few states that run their own exchanges have added subsidies of their own. New Mexico replaced the lost federal help entirely, according to the same KFF report. If your state has its own exchange, look there first.
Where the Line Sits for Your Household
Credits for 2027 coverage are measured against the 2026 poverty guidelines. In the 48 contiguous states and D.C.:
| Household size | Poverty guideline | 400% (the cliff) |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | $15,960 | $63,840 |
| 2 | $21,640 | $86,560 |
| 3 | $27,320 | $109,280 |
| 4 | $33,000 | $132,000 |
Alaska and Hawaii use higher figures. "Household" means your tax household: you, your spouse if you file jointly, and anyone you claim as a dependent, whether or not they need coverage.
There's a floor as well. The same HealthCare.gov page notes that below 100% of the poverty level you probably won't qualify for a credit, and in states that expanded Medicaid, income under 138% points you to Medicaid instead of a marketplace plan. A retiree living entirely on cash savings for a year can end up with too little income on paper.
What Counts as Income
The number that matters is modified adjusted gross income. For this purpose, the IRS defines it as the adjusted gross income on your tax return plus three things: nontaxable Social Security benefits, tax-exempt interest, and excluded foreign income.
For someone who has stopped working, that means these all count:
- Withdrawals from a traditional IRA or 401(k), and pension payments
- The amount of any Roth conversion
- Capital gains, including long-term gains that fall in the 0% tax bracket. No tax is due on them, but they're still part of adjusted gross income
- Interest and dividends, including municipal bond interest
- Social Security, all of it, not only the taxable part
- Wages from part-time or consulting work, and rental income
And these don't:
- Qualified Roth IRA withdrawals, which the IRS treats as tax-free
- Money you spend out of checking or savings
- The part of a brokerage sale that is your original cost. Only the gain counts
- Gifts and loan proceeds
HealthCare.gov's income estimating steps walk through the same calculation starting from last year's return.
The Levers You Can Pull
Most working people can't do much about their income. Retirees living off savings can, because they decide which account each dollar comes from.
Choose the account. Suppose you need $90,000 to live on. Taken entirely from a traditional IRA, that's $90,000 of income and a couple is over the line. Taken as $60,000 from the IRA and $30,000 from savings or a Roth, it's $60,000 of income for the same spending.
Size Roth conversions to the gap. The years between leaving work and starting Medicare are popular for Roth conversions because income is low. Every dollar converted also moves you toward the cliff. In marketplace years, the conversion amount is whatever room is left after your other income, less a cushion.
Time capital gains. Selling appreciated funds to raise cash, or harvesting gains at the 0% rate, adds to income either way. When you have a choice, sell the lots with the highest cost, or take gains in a year when you're on an employer plan or Medicare.
Use the calendar. Credits are based on income for the year you're covered, not the year before. If you're retiring at the end of December and still on an employer plan, a conversion or a large sale completed before January 1 lands in a year when it can't hurt your credit. It may cost more in income tax this year, so run both sides.
Pair a bronze plan with a health savings account. Since January 1, 2026, bronze and catastrophic plans count as HSA-compatible. The 2027 contribution limits are $4,500 for self-only coverage and $9,000 for family coverage, and KFF notes that HSA contributions can lower the income figure used for the credit. Traditional IRA contributions can too, but you need taxable compensation to make them, which many early retirees don't have.
Think about Social Security timing. Starting benefits at 62 adds the whole benefit to this calculation, not only the taxable portion. That can be enough on its own to push a couple over.
Leave a Cushion, Because the Repayment Cap Is Gone
When you enroll, you estimate next year's income and the credit is paid to your insurer in advance each month. You settle up on your tax return.
Through 2025, if you'd underestimated, there were limits on how much you had to pay back. The 2025 budget law removed them. The IRS now says that for tax years after 2025, you must repay the full amount by which your advance payments exceed the credit you turned out to qualify for.
For the couple in the opening example, a year-end mutual fund distribution they didn't see coming could turn into a $27,000 tax bill the following April. Aim well below the line, not at it. Look at what your funds paid out in past Decembers before you settle on a number, and if your income changes during the year, update your marketplace application so the advance payments adjust.
When You Can Handle This Yourself
If your expected income is nowhere near the line in either direction, there's nothing to engineer. Estimate carefully, enroll, and move on. The same goes if all your income comes from one or two predictable sources and you can add it up on a sheet of paper.
It gets harder when you're within $10,000 or so of the cliff and have traditional accounts, Roth accounts, and a taxable brokerage account to draw from, particularly if conversions are part of the plan. The health insurance math and the income tax math pull in different directions, and the answer changes each year until Medicare starts.
That's a reasonable thing to hire out for a few hours. An advice-only planner will give you specific recommendations on which accounts to draw from and how much to convert, while you keep the accounts at your own brokerage and place the transactions yourself. Based on data from 97 advice-only planners on the Advice-Only Network (March 2026), hourly work runs a median of $300 per hour and a one-time comprehensive plan runs a median of $3,000. A tax preparer who works with retirees can do the income projection as well.
The Dates
On HealthCare.gov, open enrollment for 2027 runs through January 15. You need to enroll by December 15 for coverage that starts January 1. State-run exchanges set their own deadlines.
If you're choosing a plan this month, our guide to what a planner can help with during open enrollment covers the plan comparison itself. The income estimate you enter on the application is the number everything above is about, so work it out before you log in.
Ready to find an advice-only financial advisor?
Every advisor in our network charges transparent fees with zero product sales or AUM charges.
Browse Advisors